Bakery news and occasional offers. Subscribe for emails.
FAQ
You can place an order directly through the website. Simply choose your treats, select your preferred pickup or shipping option, and complete checkout.
Full payment is required when your order is placed.
The Shy Cookie Girl is a cottage bakery based in Walhalla, South Carolina.
I do not have a storefront, but I offer local pickup in Walhalla and seasonal pickup at the Clemson Farmers Market.
Yes! Local pickup is available at the following times:
Walhalla — Saturdays
11:30 AM–12:30 PM or 4:00–5:00 PM
Ingles parking lot
Clemson Farmers Market — Wednesdays
3:00–6:00 PM • May–September
Your preferred pickup option can be selected at checkout.
For the next available pickup or shipping date:
Clemson Wednesday pickup: Order by Monday at noon
Walhalla Saturday pickup: Order by Wednesday at noon
Monday or Tuesday shipping: Order by Saturday at noon
Larger orders may require additional preparation time, so please reach out before placing an order of more than 24 cookies.
Yes! Shipping is available within South Carolina only.
Orders ship on Mondays and Tuesdays to help keep your cookies fresh. Most orders ship for a flat rate of $8.
You’ll receive tracking information when your order ships.
Unfortunately, specific arrival dates cannot be guaranteed. Shipping times can vary once your order is in the carrier's hands.
The Shy Cookie Girl is not responsible for shipping delays, lost or damaged packages, or incorrect addresses provided at checkout.
Most orders ship for a flat $8 fee. Larger or bulk orders may require an additional shipping fee due to increased shipping costs.
Yes! Custom orders may be available depending on the size, date, and details of your order.
For larger orders, events, or something you'd like to customize, please reach out before ordering so we can discuss what you're looking for and make sure I have enough time to prepare it.
Orders can be changed or cancelled within 24 hours of placing your order.
After that 24-hour window, changes or cancellations may not be possible.
If I make a mistake with your order—such as a missing or incorrect item—please let me know. I’ll make it right with a replacement or full refund at no additional cost.
Because taste and texture are subjective, refunds are not offered based on personal preferences regarding taste, texture, or flavor.
Yes. Products from The Shy Cookie Girl are made in a kitchen that processes wheat, eggs, dairy, soy, and nuts.
Because of this, I cannot guarantee an allergen-free product or accommodate customers with food allergies at this time.
If you have a dietary restriction, please reach out before placing your order so I can let you know whether I may be able to accommodate it.
Absolutely! Cookies are great for parties, showers, weddings, birthdays, work events, and other celebrations.
For orders of more than 24 cookies, please contact me ahead of time. Larger orders may require additional preparation time and may not be available for the next pickup date.
Please let me know as soon as possible if you can't make your scheduled pickup.
Orders that aren't picked up within 24 hours may be disposed of for food safety and quality reasons and are not eligible for a refund.
No. The Shy Cookie Girl is a home-based cottage bakery, so there isn't a storefront to visit.
Cookies are available through online ordering, local pickup, shipping within South Carolina, and select markets and events.
I participate in select local markets and events throughout the year. Follow The Shy Cookie Girl on social media or check the website for upcoming dates and locations.
Yes! I bake orders according to my production schedule so your cookies are prepared as close to pickup or shipping as possible.
For the best texture and flavor, keep your cookies in their packaging and store them according to the storage instructions provided with your order. If you aren't planning to enjoy them right away, freezing is a great option for keeping cookies longer.
Yes! Cookies make a pretty great gift. You can place an order for someone else and provide their information for pickup or shipping at checkout.
If you're ordering for a gift or special occasion, feel free to reach out if you'd like help making the order extra special.
You can choose from the available pickup times at checkout. If you need a different time or location, please contact me at least 24 hours in advance, and I'll do my best to accommodate you.
No problem! Send me a message or email and I'll be happy to help.
Hours this week: Mon-Fri 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM · Sat 11:00 AM to 5:00 PM · Sun 11:00 AM to 5:00 PM
The Shy Cookie Girl
Bakery-style cookies, baked fresh in small batches in Walhalla, SC.
